Giving you the NFL at it's finest

2012 NFL Draft: Top 5 Most Overrated Prospects

with one comment

Blaine Gabbert

Every year in the Draft, prospects who are mostly average in college somehow manage to get completely overrated leading up to the Draft and get picked far too high.

Take last year’s Draft for example. The Jaguars watched on as Missouri quarterback Blaine Gabbert fell to number ten in the Draft and then decided to pick him as many scouts described him as a possible ‘Franchise Quarterback.’

In reality however, Gabbert was pretty much an average college quarterback who had been overrated by the media and scouts alike leading up to the Draft. As it turned out, Gabbert had an awful Rookie Season as he struggled to adapt to NFL defenses.

However, It’s not just Gabbert that was drafted to high becuase it happens every year. Prospects are hyped up by the media to be made out to be potential NFL stars but turn out to be simply average NFL players.

Which players are overrated this year? Here is a list of prospects who I believe are overrated and you may see a few names that might surprise you.

Quinton Coples

5. Quinton Coples- Defensive End- North Carolina

Why he’s overrated: Coples is a player who has shown flashes of greatness during his college career but hasn’t always delivered on a consistent basis. Projected to be picked as high as number 7 by the Jacksonville Jaguars, I just don’t think that he’s consistent enough to be worthy of a top ten pick.

Despite entering his senior year with high expectations, he struggled in rushing the passer and finished the season with only 7.5 sacks. With many teams looking at picking a pass rusher in the first round, Coples faces plenty of competition from players such as Nick Perry and Melvin Ingram.

Unfortunately for Coples, I see him being picked in the middle of the first round somewhere between the Jets at number 16 and the Patriots at number 27.

Stephen Hill

4. Stephen Hill- Wide Receiver- Georgia Tech

Why he’s overrated: Despite rising up draft boards due to his explosive 40 yard dash time of 4.36, I still consider Hill to be an overrated player. He finished his college career with only 49 catches and 9 touchdowns in three seasons and those numbers suggest that he is more of a track star than he is a future NFL star.

Hill is certainly not a complete receiver and appears to have been a product of a very high powered Georgia Tech offense. There’s no doubting that he has great speed but similar to Darius Heyward-Bey, this doesn’t always translate to him getting open down the field.

It’s a shame that the Oakland Raiders don’t have a first round pick, expect him to go somewhere in the middle picks of round 2.

Vontaze Burfict

3. Vontaze Burfict- Middle Linebacker- Arizona State

Why he’s overrated: Burfict has had an astonishing fall from grace since the college season ended and he’s seen his draft stock fall drastically over the last few months. An awful showing at the Combine has forced many scouts to go back and look at his college tape and it’s not good.

Burfict just doesn’t show the type of burst and acceleration that you would expect from a prospect who was once expected to be the Draft’s best middle linebacker. His attitude problem has also led to him being placed on this list after he blamed his own teammates and coaches for his disappointing play last season.

Despite being a talented player, I wouldn’t take a chance on Burfict until Rounds 4/5.

Alshon Jeffery

2. Alshon Jeffery- Wide Receiver- South Carolina

Why he’s overrated: Depending on which scout you speak to, Jeffery is either a top 10 pick or a late second round prospect. He had an underwhelming season last year at South Carolina and finished the year with just 49 catches for 762 receiving yards.

Many people think that Jeffery’s struggles have something to do with the poor quarterback play from last season, I’m sorry but I just see that as an excuse for his lack of production. He just isn’t a consistent enough route-runner to be considered a first round pick nor does he have the quick release from the line of scrimmage that is needed to separate from defenders in the NFL.

I see Jeffery as a late second to early third round prospect who could contribute plenty in the redzone but will likely struggle to ever become a true number 1 wide receiver in the NFL.

Ryan Tannehill

1. Ryan Tannehill Quarterback- Texas A&M

Why he’s overrated: In my opinion, Ryan Tannehill is not a first round quarterback. He has only two years of college football experience as a quarterback and the former wide receiver is still a long way away from being a complete passer.

Many scouts see him as a guaranteed top 10 pick and he has even been projected to go as high as number 4 to the Cleveland Browns. That is much too high of a risk to take on a player who has been hyped up far too much and could turn out to be this year’s Blaine Gabbert.

Despite having plenty of potential, I just wouldn’t feel comfortable spending a high first round pick on Tannehill and wouldn’t be willing to pick him until the second round.

So those are my top 5 most overrated prospects in the upcoming Draft. Check back next week as I reveal my top 5 most underrated prospects.

Follow me on twitter for further updates.

Thanks for reading.


Written by podgeoh92

April 9, 2012 at 9:51 am

Posted in College Football, NFL Draft

Tagged with

One Response

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Not quite as crazy about this list as compared to your underrated list, but you make good points. Burfict has been exposed and may not get drafted. Coples has enormous talent but will bust with the wrong team. Here’s what I see in him: A guy who will pad his personal stats but miss the tackle on a running play that nets the other team a first down. Jeffrey is sliding down draft boards but he’s tough to cover one on one and S Car had QB issues. I do give him a chance. Not sure about Hill. Tannehill is a 2nd-3rd round guy who is likely to need time to develop. If he sits 2 years, maybe he does develop. If he’s thrown in like Gabbert, that could hurt. I would draft him at #22 if I was Cleveland but of course he doesn’t fall that far.

    Thanks again,



    April 17, 2012 at 5:56 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: